Head-to-head
Lodge 12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet vs Smithey No. 12
Lodge 12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet leads: the AI models rank it above its rival on 1 of the 1 leaderboard they share. Based on how ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini & Grok rank both across the leaderboard they share — re-polled on demand, reasoning shown verbatim.
| Leaderboard | Lodge 12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet | Smithey No. 12 |
|---|---|---|
| Best cast iron skillet for steaks? | #1 / 10 | #2 / 10 |
Why the models rank Lodge 12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet — on best cast iron skillet for steaks?
“Best balance of value and steak performance: its roughly 8-pound mass and 10-inch cooking floor accommodate two typical steaks while resisting temperature drop, and its durable factory seasoning, helper handle, and low price are hard to beat. Near-tie with Victoria; Lodge wins for steak-first use because it retains more heat.”
Why the models rank Smithey No. 12 — on best cast iron skillet for steaks?
“Machined-smooth, polished cooking surface that behaves almost like vintage Griswold, releases well early, generous flared walls and a helper handle for steak flipping and basting; a genuine buy-it-for-life piece. FIX: ~$200 price and lighter than a comparable Lodge — hard to justify over a $25 pan on pure searing performance for most people.”
More head-to-heads
Rankings move. Know when this flips.
The 3 biggest AI-ranking flips, one short email a week.
Ranks from the merged 4-model leaderboards · re-polled on demand · methodology