ModelsAgree
← All leaderboards
🖨️

Best home printer under $100 for students?

2 models · updated 2026-07-07

The verdict

Canon PIXMA TR4720 leads — 0 of 2 models rank Canon PIXMA TR4720 the top pick.

Not unanimous: ChatGPT picks Brother MFC-J1010DW; Claude picks Brother HL-L2405W.

Combined ranking

  1. 1
    Canon PIXMA TR472017 pts
    GPT #2Claude #3

    Strong cheap all-in-one with ADF, auto two-sided printing, compact footprint, reliable mobile printing, and better photo/color output than many budget rivals

    To stay #1 Faster print speeds

  2. 2
    HP DeskJet 4255e35 pts
    GPT #5Claude #2

    The best-rounded all-in-one under $80 — print, copy, scan with wireless that's genuinely reliable through the HP app, and optional Instant Ink can keep costs predictable for light users.

    To rank higher Decouple the good experience from HP's ink ecosystem — high standard cartridge costs and aggressive HP+ / account-signup requirements are the main reason it loses to the Brother laser.

  3. 3
    Brother HL-L2405Wnew5 pts
    GPT Claude #1

    Monochrome laser at ~$99 with the lowest real cost-per-page of anything in this bracket — toner doesn't dry out between semesters, it prints essays and problem sets fast (30ppm) with duplex, and Wi-Fi plus AirPrint means it just works from a laptop or phone in a dorm.

    To rank higher Add a flatbed scanner — students constantly need to scan/copy syllabi and IDs, and its print-only design forces many buyers down to an inkjet all-in-one.

  4. 4
    Brother MFC-J1010DW35 pts
    GPT #1Claude

    Best student feature set under $100: automatic duplex printing, 20-sheet ADF, scan/copy/fax, good text speed, Wi-Fi, and solid everyday document output

    To rank higher Much lower ink cost per page

  5. 5
    HP ENVY 6155e23 pts
    GPT #3Claude

    Clean setup, good-looking documents and occasional photos, auto duplex, strong app support, AirPrint, and Instant Ink can make sense for predictable student printing

    To rank higher Lower cartridge costs without requiring a subscription

  6. 6
    Epson Expression Home XP-420022 pts
    GPT #4Claude

    Compact, easy to use, auto duplex, individual ink cartridges, sharp text, and good enough color quality for coursework and handouts

    To rank higher Add an automatic document feeder

  7. 7
    Epson WorkForce WF-2930new2 pts
    GPT Claude #4

    Frequently $69-99 on sale with ADF, decent scan quality, and solid document output; Epson's no-HP+-style-lock-in approach appeals to students who hate subscriptions.

    To rank higher Improve reliability and print speed — it's slow (~10ppm black) and Epson's frequent printhead-cleaning cycles waste already-small cartridges.

  8. 8
    HP DeskJet 2855enew1 pts
    GPT Claude #5

    Regularly $49-60, making it the lowest entry price for a working print/copy/scan machine — fine for a student who prints a handful of pages a month and needs occasional scans.

    To rank higher Add auto duplex and cheaper ink — single-sided-only printing and pricey cartridges mean anyone with regular coursework outgrows it in a semester.

Rank history

Product06-3007-07
Canon PIXMA TR472023
HP DeskJet 4255e52
Brother HL-L2405W·1
Brother MFC-J1010DW1·
HP ENVY 6155e3·
Epson Expression Home XP-42004·
Epson WorkForce WF-2930·4
HP DeskJet 2855e·5

By model

ChatGPT

  1. 1.Brother MFC-J1010DW
  2. 2.Canon PIXMA TR4720
  3. 3.HP ENVY 6155e
  4. 4.Epson Expression Home XP-4200
  5. 5.HP DeskJet 4255e

Claude

  1. 1.Brother HL-L2405W
  2. 2.HP DeskJet 4255e
  3. 3.Canon PIXMA TR4720
  4. 4.Epson WorkForce WF-2930
  5. 5.HP DeskJet 2855e

Tracked by ModelsAgree · rank 1 = 5 pts … rank 5 = 1 pt · re-polled continuously