ModelsAgree
← All leaderboards
🖨️

Best home printer under $300 for students?

2 models · updated 2026-07-07

The verdict

Brother MFC-J1010DW leads — 1 of 2 models rank Brother MFC-J1010DW the top pick.

Not unanimous: ChatGPT picks Canon PIXMA MegaTank G3290.

Combined ranking

  1. 1
    Brother MFC-J1010DWnew5 pts
    GPT Claude #1

    INKvestment ink keeps cost-per-page around a cent, all-in-one with scanner/copier for homework and forms, auto duplex saves paper, reliable Wi-Fi and AirPrint, typically $180-200

    To stay #1 Faster print speeds (17ppm mono is modest) and a sharper flatbed scanner would make it unbeatable for the price.

  2. 2
    Canon PIXMA MegaTank G329015 pts
    GPT #1Claude

    very low ink cost, strong text/photo quality, automatic duplex printing, touchscreen, reliable all-in-one value under $300

    To rank higher add an automatic document feeder

  3. 3
    Epson EcoTank ET-2400new4 pts
    GPT Claude #2

    Refillable tanks mean roughly two years of ink in the box and pennies-per-page after, ideal for high-volume essay printing on a student budget, compact and around $200

    To rank higher Add an auto-document feeder and duplex printing, which students constantly need for multi-page readings and double-sided submissions.

  4. 4
    Epson EcoTank ET-285024 pts
    GPT #2Claude

    excellent long-term ink economy, compact student-friendly design, automatic duplex printing, good document and photo output

    To rank higher print faster

  5. 5
    Brother HL-L2460DWnew3 pts
    GPT Claude #3

    Mono laser workhorse — fast 36ppm, crisp text for papers, cheap high-yield toner, auto duplex, and toner never dries out during semester breaks, usually about $140

    To rank higher It only prints; a color or scan capability would lift it above the all-in-ones for students who need to digitize handouts.

  6. 6
    HP Smart Tank 700133 pts
    GPT #3Claude

    low bottled-ink running cost, faster text printing than many budget tanks, 250-sheet tray, easy wireless setup

    To rank higher add an automatic document feeder

  7. 7
    Brother MFC-J4535DW32 pts
    GPT #4Claude

    fast document printing, large paper capacity, automatic document feeder, sharp text, strong home-office features under $300

    To rank higher switch from cartridges to refillable tanks

  8. 8
    Canon PIXMA TR8720anew2 pts
    GPT Claude #4

    Rare full-feature set under $250 — ADF, fax, duplex, five-ink system with sharp photo output for design or lab-report projects, strong app support

    To rank higher Cartridge ink costs run high per page; a tank-based or subscription-friendly ink system would fix its biggest ownership expense.

  9. 9
    HP OfficeJet Pro 8135enew1 pts
    GPT Claude #5

    Fast inkjet AIO with ADF and duplex, excellent HP Smart app for scanning to PDF from a phone, often discounted near $180 with instant-ink trial credits

    To rank higher Decouple the value from HP+ / Instant Ink lock-in — third-party ink blocking and mandatory account setup frustrate students who just want a printer.

  10. 10
    HP Smart Tank 600151 pts
    GPT #5Claude

    cheap refillable ink, automatic two-sided printing, good everyday color output, simple wireless all-in-one setup

    To rank higher add an automatic document feeder

Rank history

Product06-3007-07
Brother MFC-J1010DW·1
Canon PIXMA MegaTank G32901·
Epson EcoTank ET-2400·2
Epson EcoTank ET-28502·
Brother HL-L2460DW·3
HP Smart Tank 70013·
Brother MFC-J4535DW4·
Canon PIXMA TR8720a·4

By model

ChatGPT

  1. 1.Canon PIXMA MegaTank G3290
  2. 2.Epson EcoTank ET-2850
  3. 3.HP Smart Tank 7001
  4. 4.Brother MFC-J4535DW
  5. 5.HP Smart Tank 6001

Claude

  1. 1.Brother MFC-J1010DW
  2. 2.Epson EcoTank ET-2400
  3. 3.Brother HL-L2460DW
  4. 4.Canon PIXMA TR8720a
  5. 5.HP OfficeJet Pro 8135e

Tracked by ModelsAgree · rank 1 = 5 pts … rank 5 = 1 pt · re-polled continuously